Thursday, August 14, 2014
New Posts Coming Soon
After a well deserved and restful two weeks of vacation, I'm now back
home and ready to resume work on not just my series on the walkability
of Baltimore but all the other ideas that have bubbling through my head
that are still in the research phase. Stay tuned for the completion of
the series I started and the transformation of other ideas into the
posts you see on this blog.
Friday, July 25, 2014
A More Walkable Key Highway
Key Highway acts as a gateway to the South Baltimore Peninsula. Until
recently, the South Baltimore Peninsula was home to heavy industry in
addition to Row Homes. At the time Key Highway acted as the perfect
gateway to South Baltimore with the Bethlehem Steel Shipyard in its
forefront. Well times have changed and Key Highway and the South
Baltimore Peninsula as a whole are much less industrial and much more
Residential and Retail. One thing that goes hand in hand with that type
of development is walkability. So without further ado, I give you a more
walkable Key Highway.
The face of Key Highway has changed considerably over the
past 20 years. After closing in 1984 the Bethlehem Steel shipyard lay
vacant and rotting for several years before the construction of the
Harborview Tower in 1993. This 29 story condo tower was the first of its
kind and was way ahead of its time. The developers of Harborview knew
what they were doing though. Throughout the 2000s, Harborview expanded
with a low rise condo building and 88 very large town homes. Shortly
following was the construction of the Ritz Carlton Residences although
the economic downturn of 2008 stalled construction and prices dropped
from seven figures to a mere six figures. Both Harborview and the Ritz
Carlton Residences are gated Communities.
Gated Communities don't exactly scream walkability
and welcoming environment. Residents of a gated Community are less
likely to walk places or use public transportation like the Charm City
Circulator. It also sends a message for non Residents and that message
is; Keep Out! Now I must give credit where credit is due, the Charm City
Circulator has been great at transporting Residents in the area of Key
Highway around the City and has brought many visitors as well to Key
Highway (myself included.) Walkability cannot be achieved without
something such as the Charm City Circulator and its connections to MTA
Bus Lines, MARC, and Light Rail. This in a lot of ways makes Key Highway
quite walkable.
Like most areas of the City, Key Highway is in
transition. There are still remnants of its industrial past and vacant
lots that can be developed or redeveloped. In doing so, the walkability
of Key Highway can be improved upon vastly. In keeping with my "give
credit where credit is due" theme of this post, the City released a
Master Plan for the Key Highway Waterfront addressing these issues. The
plan talked about restricting building heights (no walls of high rises)
and not blocking sight from Federal Hill.
Though there has been lots of development on Key
Highway, there are still vacant lots. For instance, Harborview is far
from complete. There are two parcels directly adjacent to the 29 story
Harborview high rise. When the market turns around, construction will
commence on the ultra upscale "Pinnacle at Harborview." Pinnacle is the
scaled back version of what was to be two high rises both of which were
to be 26 stories. Since this goes against the "the no wall of high
rises" approach, Pinnacle was dropped down to 17 stories. There are no
plans as to what the height of the third building will be. Pinnacle and
most likely the third building on that lot will be gated which will only
add to the lack of walkability that Key Highway has grown accustomed
to. How about from here on out we shy away from Gated Communities on Key
Highway?
With that in mind, lets take a walk down Key Highway
to take a look at develop-able parcels. First there's Covington St.
across from Harborview and Digital Harbor High School. There are plans
to put a high rise on this very narrow piece of land. I do not support
this and neither does the South Baltimore Community. What I do support
is 3-4 story mixed use buildings that look like Federal Place Town Homes
right behind them. The only difference is, these will have ground floor
Retail that faces Key Highway. In that same area are two pieces of
triangular land both with blighted uses that could be suited for 6 Story
Apartment Buildings with ground floor Retail.
Between Harborview and Little Havana (which is under
going a large renovation) is a parking lot that is part of the
Harvorview Property waited to be developed. That could make a 7-9 story
building with ground floor Retail along with half of the empty warehouse
next to it. The remaining half of the empty warehouse could be
demolished to give a better view of the water to Clement St and Webster
St. Residents. Webster St. and Clement St for that matter could both
made into a walkways to the pier.
On the other side of Webster St., there's a narrow
piece of property that would make for a good 12 story high rise. A
building this tall would only work here because there it wouldn't
obstruct the view of the water from other buildings. In order to ensure
walkability on Key Highway, the Fire Department Repair Shop next to
Museum of Industry would have to be demolished. In its place, another
building with Apartments and Condos but it would only be 6-8 stories.
There's a 9 story building going up at the former General Electric sight
so making this building taller than 9 stories would obstruct the view.
Both of these buildings will have ground floor Retail.
As for Key Highway itself. the road is due for a
makeover. This includes fresh asphalt pavement, red brick crosswalks,
more stylish street lights, pedestrian signals where there are none and
to replace the aging median strip with fresh red bricks and new
plantings. This doesn't make Key Highway anymore walkable per-se but it
creates a more welcoming environment than what it is there now and how
welcoming the environment is translates into how walkable the Community
is. Stay tuned for my next article in the series.
Monday, July 21, 2014
Hampden-Woodberry: The Gold Standard of Walkability
I actually had no intention or idea I would be writing this article. I
figured I would start this series by addressing areas I thought
walkability or lack there of, would be the start. However, I took a walk
around the area yesterday near the Light Rail Stop and up 41st St. all
the way to the Rotunda and back. Well actually some that was journey was
with the help of the Hampden Shuttle Bug. I couldn't help but realize
how incredibly the walkable the Community is and how beautiful the area
is as well. Hampden-Woodberry, I christen thee the Gold Standard of
Walkability.
The history of Hampden-Woodberry is all around us. Most
of the new development that has come to the pipeline recently actually
hasn't been new at all. It has been the restoration of the Mills that
were once the major Employers of the Mill Villages that would become
Hampden-Woodberry. It wasn't until recently that the Mills were thought
of as assets to the Neighborhood, in fact it was quite the contrary. The
Mills were old blighted and boarded up.
36th St. or the Avenue was and still is the piece de
resistance of Hampden. Woodberry seemed to be worlds away as it was not
only west of Falls Road but also west of the JFX. It should be
mentioned that before the JFXs construction, Hampden and Woodberry were
seamlessly together. As the Avenue began breathing new life into
Hampden, it seemed that the Light Rail Stop was worlds away. After all,
it was in Woodberry which at the time was in the middle of nowhere and
the Avenue was in Hampden. Of course the Light Rail Stop is just a few
blocks away from the Avenue but given the "no man's land" status of the
Light Rail Stop and that it was near the vacant mills, very few utilized
it.
The Real reason the Light Rail Stop wasn't used by
Hampdenites, was because it just wasn't that walkable. Given the fact
that many new Residents in Hampden don't have cars and/or prefer
walking, there had to be a way to connect the Light Rail Stop to the
Avenue. It was then that the Shuttle Bug was conceived. The Shuttle Bug
improved Hampden's walkability by immeasurable proportions. The Shuttle
Bug runs through Hampden and Woodberry with stops on the main roads and
intersections Hampdenites better access to the Light Rail Station,
something that was lacking before hand. This also breathed new life into
Hampden west of Falls Road still closer to the Light Rail Station. This
made the walk under the JFX to get to the Light Rail Station and
Woodberry a little less scary.
As vacant row homes in Hampden began to be occupied
again, the demand for housing, retail, and office space remained. There
isn't much room for new construction so developers had to look at other
options. They began to look at the possibility of rehabbing the old
Mills that had provided employment the area for generations prior. The
interest generated by rehabbing the Poole & Hunt Complex (renamed
Clipper Mill) as mixed use sparked not only new construction on the
site, but it allowed developers to pursue rehabbing other Mills in the
area.
As the 2000s turned into the 2010s, Union Mill,
Meadow Mill, Mount Vernon Mill 1&4, and Clipper Mill (the real one)
were slated for reuse as mixed use development projects. This provided
the much needed link between the Avenue and the Woodberry Light Rail
Stop. This coupled with the Shuttle Bug gave Hampden its own Light Rail
Stop. Although the distance between the Avenue and the Light Rail Stop
hadn't changed, the only thing that had changed was its walkability. The
rehabbing of the Mills created a welcoming environment full of life and
lots of foot traffic all around the Light Rail Stop which encouraged
more Residents to use the Light Rail Stop whether they walked there or
took the Shuttle Bus. The Walkability is what ultimately reunited
Hampden-Woodberry even with the JFX.
When looking in the future to make more
Neighborhoods or Neighborhood clusters walkable, look no further than
Hampden-Woodberry, the Gold Standard.Friday, July 18, 2014
Lets Make Baltimore More Walkable
Although I consider Baltimore to be a very walkable City, there is
always room for improvement. Whether it's an additional line or stops on
the Charm City Calculator, adding more sidewalks to recently
redeveloped areas of the city, adding lighting, redevelopment of
eyesores, or just about anything to provide a more welcoming environment
to certain areas of the City, making Baltimore more walkable is key to
the continued growth of the City and to continue to add Neighborhoods to
the City's showcase. What will follow is a series of areas in the City
that I believe will benefit from being more walkable. Stay tuned for
more!
Tuesday, July 15, 2014
Marketplace at Fells Point: A Delicate but Worthwhile Endeavor
Although the Inner Harbor was the turning point for gentrification along
the waterfront, Fells Point was ground zero for Residential
Gentrification. At the time, there weren't really any Residences in the
Inner Harbor area as the site for Inner Harbor East was nothing but
surface parking lots. As Fells Point began to gentrify, two areas became
known as the crowns & jewels of Fells Point; Broadway (the two
blocks in which the Broadway Market is located) and Thames St. due to
its waterfront access.
The gentrification of Fells Point spread like wildfire to
Little Italy, Canton, Patterson Park, Butchers Hill, Greeektown,
Brewers Hill, Historic Jonestown, Inner Harbor East, Federal Hill,
Locust Point, Otterbein, and South Baltimore. A lot of these
Neighborhoods had ample space for new construction. This is something
that Fells Point doesn't have. Larger Retailers have no choice but to go
to newly constructed shopping areas like Canton Crossing, McHenry Row,
and Inner Harbor East. Thames St. does have lots of great Retail and
Restaurants but their footprints are only so big. Could Fells Point be
losing its shine? It would certainly take a delicate but worthwhile
endeavor enhance the Neighborhood.
Large plots of new construction in Fells Point are hard to come by.
The Crescent was built at Henderson's Wharf featuring Apartments &
Town Homes, other than that, rehabbing existing buildings be they Row
Homes or Industrial Buildings has been the order of the day. Granted
there have been some infill areas throughout Fells Point where new
construction has taken place. As new Retail and Residential construction
continued throughout other Harbor Neighborhoods, more and more vacant
storefronts popped up in Fells Point, most notably the 600 block of S.
Broadway. Could this be the siren call for new construction in Fells
Point?
Well not exactly, you see the 600 block of Broadway
was once one of Fells Point's show case blocks. It's just a few blocks
away from the water and Thames St. It's also just block north of the 700
block of S. Broadway where the Retail is much livelier. Perhaps the
most important reason that the 600 block of S. Broadway isn't conducive
to new construction is because the historic Boradway Market is in the
median of this block (as well as the 700 block.) It should also be noted
that the facades in the 600 block are well preserved and demolishing
them would not be beneficial.
That being said, the buildings are quite shallow and
there was land behind them on both sides of the street. In 2005, a
developer known as "South Broadway Properties LLC" began the delicate
but worthwhile endeavor of purchasing the properties on both sides of
the 600 block of South Broadway whether vacant or occupied. The intent
was and still is to turn the block into a vibrant mixed use with all
amenities of new construction while still remaining true to the
character of the surrounding blocks. The result would become Marketplace
at Fells Point. Properties in the 600 block that had been acquired and
vacated had a logo of "MP" on the windows and/or an artist's rendering
of the block thriving after construction.
So what exactly is Marketplace at Fells Point? Like I
said before, it's a mixed use development that capitalizes on the
location and the fact that the existing buildings are shallow as well as
their historic character. In order to preserve the facades of the
buildings and provide the amenities of new construction, everything but
the bricks of the front facades had to be demolished. Now you can see
how delicate this venture is, just one little mistake and the historic
facades could be just that;history.
Behind the facades would be ground floor Retail
presumably more upscale than its predecessors. The buildings will go
back deeper taking advantage of the land that was behind them. Above the
Retail, there will be 159 brand new Apartments. Not since the Crescent
at Fells Point has there been a number of new construction Residential
in Fells Point. Sure Inner Harbor East is just nect door as is Canton
but those looking for a brand new Apartment and are dead set on Fells
Point, needn't look any further.
One great thing about Marketplace at Fells Point is
that it's almost all landlocked by existing buildings. That means the
new construction doesn't stick out like a sore thumb. It's only barely
visible to the naked eye and said naked eye would have to be quite
familiar with the area in order to differentiate between the two. The
Apartments are nearing completion and are being leased up like hotcakes.
The Retail portion is still under construction but with the growth
generated from the Apartments and new Residential construction
throughout southeast Baltimore as a whole, I'm sure the Retail portion
will be just as easy to lease out to smaller footprint Retailers upon
completion.
It may have taken a while but Marketplace at Fells
Point is nearing completion and it surely has been and will continue to
be a delicate and worthwhile endeavor.
Wednesday, July 9, 2014
Not Your Great Granddaddy's Locust Point
What do you think of when you think of Locust Point? If your entire
Family generation after generation has grown up in Baltimore, they will
all have a different answer to that question. Although the answer to
that question is different among the generations, none of the answers
are wrong. The fact of the matter is, Locust Point has changed greatly
throughout the generations but has always been an important part of
Baltimore's celebrated history. Indeed, this is not your Great
Granddaddy's Locust Point.
Your Great Granddaddy might call Locust Point the first
stop for European Immigrants entering the City. This was true as there
was a direct ship line from Locust Point to Germany. Immigrants all
throughout Eastern Europe traveled to Germany to travel to Baltimore
entering in Locust Point. It wasn't just German and Eastern European
Immigrants who emigrated to Baltimore. Irish, Scots-Irish, Italian, and
Greek Immigrants also arrived in Baltimore via Locust Point.
Your Granddaddy might call Locust Point a thriving
Industrial and Residential Community filled with Shipping Channels,
Factories, the world's largest Grain Elevator, and classic Baltimore Row
Homes. This rang true for every Neighborhood with waterfront access and
Locust Point was no different. The biggest names in manufacturing in
Locust Point were Domino Sugar (pictured above), and Proctor and Gamble
(Tide Point.) Workers in these Factories and Shipping Channels didn't
have to travel far between work and home as the row homes in Locust
Point housed those worked in the Neighborhood.
Now your Daddy might call Locust Point a Community
struggling to maintain its industrial roots. As industry began to
decline in America, so too did the Factories and Shipping Channel in
Locust Point. Layoffs were all too commonplace as the workforce needed
grew smaller. Some Locust Point Residents sought employment elsewhere
and moved away. Others stayed put knowing no other home. Although Locust
Point had lost some population just like the City as a whole, the rate
was not nearly as high and residential urban decay was quite rare
considering magnitude at which the workforce was cut.
Today, Locust Point is a hot bed for reinvestment
and redevelopment. It seems every time you turn a corner there are new
Apartments, Condos, Town Homes, and Retail being built or proposed. In
the 2000s, several new developments were either built as new
construction or existing industrial buildings were rehabbed for new
uses. They include, Silo Point Condos (Old Grain Elevator), Tide Point
Office Park, The Townes at Locust Point, Harbour Point
Town Homes (not to be confused with Harbor Point), and McHenry Point
located between Silo Point (pictured below) and Fort McHenry.
These new developments mostly containing Town Homes
have renewed interest in Locust Point and has caused further development
to continue. Old pieces of land that was once industrial now is flanked
with new Town Homes that although larger than their older Row Home
counterparts, don't look out of place.
More recently the celebrated McHenry Row has brought
a Harris Teeter along with an upscale selection of Retail, Offices, and
Apartments to Locust Point in a compact footprint complete with parking
garages. Just across Key Highway, the once Blue Collar Southside
Marketplace has received a multi million dollar renovation that has seen
more upscale stores move into vacant spaces. I guess my old post
"Southside Marketplace: Get With the Times" didn't fall on deaf ears.
Across from Southside Marketplace is the site of a
demolished GE Service Center (pictured above) on the 900 block of Fort
Avenue. The Buzzuto Group is proposing a nine story mixed use Apartment
Retail Building that will cater to fitness buffs. The Apartment building
will contain a yoga studio and indoor pool and a rooftop lounge.
Although taller than other buildings in Locust Point, this new building
site seems like the perfect location for something taller given that
it's a Community Gateway.
At first there plans to make expand Tide Point (pictured above), by
adding mixed use. This idea was nixed when a tenant known as "Under
Armour" decided to take over the entire complex and build on the site
meant for mixed use. Under Armour has helped breathe new life into the
employment sector of Locust Point and help make it an even bigger draw
than it already is. The future does indeed look bright for Locust Point.
From being known as Baltimore's "Ellis Island", to
thriving Industrial Community, to the poster child for industrial
down-sizing, to hip upscale waterfront magnet, it is clear that Locust
Point has changed drastically over the generations and that this is not
your Great Granddaddy's Locust Point. But I end this post with a
question; What will Locust Point be for your Great Grandchildren?
Thursday, July 3, 2014
Central Avenue: A Makeover at Last
There was once was a time when Central Avenue lived up to its name. It actually was in the "center" of the settlement once known as Baltimoretown. With the first three settlements being Jonestown, Oldtown, and Fells Point, it's easy to see why Central Avenue was given the name it carries to this day. Obviously some 623,000 Residents and several hundred years later, Baltimore is a different place but Central Avenue has a "center point" for Neighborhoods just southeast of Downtown.
Although Central Avenue is located near rapidly gentrifying Neighborhoods such as Little Italy, Inner Harbor East, Jonestown, Fells Point, Upper Fells Point, and eventually Harbor Point, Central Avenue really isn't a part of any of them. It does divide these Neighborhoods by creating a north south spine that cuts what should be a blending together of Neighborhoods with distinct identities yet all remain true assets to Baltimore as a whole.
Now how did Central Avenue get like this? My theory is that it was always seen as a diving line between Residential Neighborhoods, just look at all the dingy auto shops and low quality Retail that flanks the road. It may have been beneficial in the olden days to have such a dividing line in between these Residential Neighborhoods. Though as a whole southeast Baltimore was ethnically diverse, individual Neighborhoods were not. Little Italy was and still is Italian, Jonestown was historically home to Eastern European Jews, Fells Point and Upper Fells Point was divided into sections of Irish, German, and Polish Backgrounds. Although there are still vestiges remaining of their ethnic pasts still remaining in these communities, these Neighborhoods now play host to every culture and ethnicity under the sun.
So who lived in Inner Harbor East and Harbor Point? Back in their heyday, these communities took full advantage of their proximity to the water. In short, heavy industry lined the docks for importing and exporting and on the main land that is now flanked with ultra upscale Apartments, Offices, Boutiques, and Five Star Hotels was pure factories. In fact pretty much all of Harbor Point was taken up by the Allied Signal Chromium Plant, a major Employer for southeast Baltimore from 1845 up until the 1980s. Given its toxic manufacturing practices, the land that it once occupied was deemed contaminated when the factory closed. That meant a long decades long process of cleaning it up and making it suitable for development. If you were wondering why Harbor Point has remained vacant for so long, there's your answer.
The southern end of Central Avenue was and is where the blurred line separating Inner Harbor East and Harbor Point. The last remaining parcels of undeveloped land all have Central Avenue frontage. The southern most block of Central Avenue contains a rare sight in the high density Inner Harbor East; a surface level parking garage. Further up you will H&S Bakery's plant campus, the last remaining industry in the area. Although the area surrounding Central Avenue has been gentrified and redeveloped, Central Avenue itself remained elusive of that change until now. Finally, at last Central Avenue will get its long overdue makeover.
So what exactly does this makeover include? In addition to the extension to Harbor Point, the existing Central Avenue will receive streetscape enhancements, new pavement, a landscaped median, sidewalks, crosswalks, improved street lighting, and "mast arm" traffic signals. This will make Central Avenue more attractive for rehabbing vacant industrial buildings as mixed use Residential/Retail. Perhaps if any of the plethora of auto shop garages were to go out of business, a more attractive streetscape on Central Avenue will entice redevelopment of the site that houses a shuttered auto garage.
Fortunately gentrification has sprung up along certain parts of Central Avenue already. Part of the Holland Manufacturing Building has been leased to the Heavy Seas Alehouse and another portion has been leased to "Edges" Salon & Spa. There are other spaces available to lease as well. The Canal St. Malt House has been converted into Loft Styles Condos as well. In addition to Retail and Residential popping up in old Industrial Buildings, Start up E-Commerce Company known as "Groove Commerce" has moved into the old Fallsway Spring Building.
Although Central Avenue is surrounded by some of Baltimore's most sought after Neighborhoods, the road itself is still quite ugly. There are some exceptions with signs of life rehabbing old buildings but there's a lot more work to be done. Fortunately, the City and Harbor Point's Developer have taken notice and Central Avenue will get a makeover at last.
Although Central Avenue is located near rapidly gentrifying Neighborhoods such as Little Italy, Inner Harbor East, Jonestown, Fells Point, Upper Fells Point, and eventually Harbor Point, Central Avenue really isn't a part of any of them. It does divide these Neighborhoods by creating a north south spine that cuts what should be a blending together of Neighborhoods with distinct identities yet all remain true assets to Baltimore as a whole.
Now how did Central Avenue get like this? My theory is that it was always seen as a diving line between Residential Neighborhoods, just look at all the dingy auto shops and low quality Retail that flanks the road. It may have been beneficial in the olden days to have such a dividing line in between these Residential Neighborhoods. Though as a whole southeast Baltimore was ethnically diverse, individual Neighborhoods were not. Little Italy was and still is Italian, Jonestown was historically home to Eastern European Jews, Fells Point and Upper Fells Point was divided into sections of Irish, German, and Polish Backgrounds. Although there are still vestiges remaining of their ethnic pasts still remaining in these communities, these Neighborhoods now play host to every culture and ethnicity under the sun.
So who lived in Inner Harbor East and Harbor Point? Back in their heyday, these communities took full advantage of their proximity to the water. In short, heavy industry lined the docks for importing and exporting and on the main land that is now flanked with ultra upscale Apartments, Offices, Boutiques, and Five Star Hotels was pure factories. In fact pretty much all of Harbor Point was taken up by the Allied Signal Chromium Plant, a major Employer for southeast Baltimore from 1845 up until the 1980s. Given its toxic manufacturing practices, the land that it once occupied was deemed contaminated when the factory closed. That meant a long decades long process of cleaning it up and making it suitable for development. If you were wondering why Harbor Point has remained vacant for so long, there's your answer.
The southern end of Central Avenue was and is where the blurred line separating Inner Harbor East and Harbor Point. The last remaining parcels of undeveloped land all have Central Avenue frontage. The southern most block of Central Avenue contains a rare sight in the high density Inner Harbor East; a surface level parking garage. Further up you will H&S Bakery's plant campus, the last remaining industry in the area. Although the area surrounding Central Avenue has been gentrified and redeveloped, Central Avenue itself remained elusive of that change until now. Finally, at last Central Avenue will get its long overdue makeover.
Harbor Point is what brought on the need for the makeover. Right not Central Avenue dead ends at Lancaster St. In order to make Harbor Point viable for development a bridge will be built over the water extending Central Avenue to Harbor Point. In fact, one could argue that Central Avenue will act as the gateway to Harbor Point. As the groundbreaking for Harbor Point draws closer, the remaining pieces of Inner Harbor East are falling into place. The blocks of Central Avenue containing the surface lot and H&S Bakery will be redeveloped into high end mixed use like the rest of Inner Harbor East. Something tells me that convincing H&S Bakery owner John Paderakis to move his plant wasn't a hard sell. After all he is the developer of Inner Harbor East and bought up all the land surrounding H&S Bakery starting in 1984. 
So why is Central Avenue so ugly? My guess is that even though it's surrounded by nice showcase Neighborhoods, it's not like actually in them. Although it does cut through Inner Harbor East, John Paterkais has yet to relocate his H&S Bakery for redevelopment. Luckily the City and the Developers of Harbor Point are finally ready to give Central Avenue its much needed makeover. One big reason the Developers of Harbor Point are interested in improving Central Avenue is due to the fact that they will be extended it past Lancaster St. via a bridge over the water right onto the site for Harbor Point. Fortunately, with the City's help, the Developers of Harbor Point will be giving Central Avenue a makeover from Lancaster St. all the way to Madison St. So what exactly does this makeover include? In addition to the extension to Harbor Point, the existing Central Avenue will receive streetscape enhancements, new pavement, a landscaped median, sidewalks, crosswalks, improved street lighting, and "mast arm" traffic signals. This will make Central Avenue more attractive for rehabbing vacant industrial buildings as mixed use Residential/Retail. Perhaps if any of the plethora of auto shop garages were to go out of business, a more attractive streetscape on Central Avenue will entice redevelopment of the site that houses a shuttered auto garage.
Fortunately gentrification has sprung up along certain parts of Central Avenue already. Part of the Holland Manufacturing Building has been leased to the Heavy Seas Alehouse and another portion has been leased to "Edges" Salon & Spa. There are other spaces available to lease as well. The Canal St. Malt House has been converted into Loft Styles Condos as well. In addition to Retail and Residential popping up in old Industrial Buildings, Start up E-Commerce Company known as "Groove Commerce" has moved into the old Fallsway Spring Building.
Although Central Avenue is surrounded by some of Baltimore's most sought after Neighborhoods, the road itself is still quite ugly. There are some exceptions with signs of life rehabbing old buildings but there's a lot more work to be done. Fortunately, the City and Harbor Point's Developer have taken notice and Central Avenue will get a makeover at last.
Thursday, June 26, 2014
The Demise of the Central Business District and the Rise of Mixed Use
There's a development phenomenon taking our Nation's Cities by storm.
That phenomenon? Mixed Use Development. Although Mixed Use Development
has always had a place in our Cities, areas that were once solely
Retail, Commercial, Residential, Recreational, or industrial have now
been divided to house all of the above land uses in compact high density
Neighborhoods. Baltimore is no different as Neighborhoods especially
Downtown are suffering from a bit of an identity crisis as a result
especially Downtown's Central Business District.
Up until the 1960s, mixed use was much more commonplace.
Then during the flight to the suburbs, industry as we knew it died
leaving swaths of vacant land throughout (pictured above), a lot of these vacant
industrial Neighborhoods are today's Inner Harbor . Also the City pushed
to rid Neighborhoods of "Corner Stores" which they believed was
contributing to the escalating crime rate. Downtown, there was the
Central Business District and the Westside of Downtown which had been
the City's Shopping District.
As suburban Shopping Malls began popping up
throughout the suburbs, fewer and fewer Shoppers graced the Westside of
Downtown, a problem that City Leaders and Private Developers are trying
to remedy to this day. The Central Business District however has had a
luckier fate. James Rouse who ironically built a large portion of the
suburban shopping Malls that bled the City as of its destination Retail
status stepped in to save the Central Business District. At the time the
Central Business District had old Buildings that would not or could not
compete with newer Office Buildings being built in the suburbs. With
that Charles Center was born.
Charles Center was a no nonsense redevelopment that
got rid of what was left of the old Office Buildings as well as
Buildings with other uses. This only helped the City do away with mixed
use. Charles Center also walled itself off from Neighboring Districts
with its intrusive Office Buildings in an attempt wall itself off from
the blight that those Neighborhoods were experiencing. South of Charles
Center however, the walled off concept was not to be.
The Inner Harbor, one of the industrial areas that
had been abandoned was the target for another Rouse Company
redevelopment project. This time buildings would not be sky scrapers, in
fact they would be short in stature so as not to obstruct views from
the water. The beginning of the Inner Harbor redevelopment was also the
beginning of the rebirth of mixed in Baltimore. The first pieces of the
Inner Harbor included the Promenade (Recreational), Harbor Place
(Retail), and the Science Center and Aquarium (Institutional). Shortly
there after the Residential components began to take shape by rehabbing
Row Homes in Otterbein, Federal Hill, and Fells Point.
Shortly after the successful beginnings of the Inner
Harbor, John Paterakis, who earned his fortune with the successful
H&S Bakery turned developer and took the bold move of buying the
huge swaths of vacant industrial land between Little Italy, the Inner
Harbor and Fells Point. His vision was to bring in upscale high density
mixed use development known as Inner Harbor East. After decades of pit
falls, Paterakis's dream of redeveloping this land has come to fruition (pictured above).
The Mixed Use Inner Harbor East is home to Offices, Retail, Apartments,
Hotels, and an extended Promenade. A lot of the Offices that leased
space in Harbor East relocated from the Central Business District and
the Retail in both Inner Harbor East and Harbor Place could have gone to
the Westside of Downtown. But that's old world thinking, Mixed Use is
all the rage.
As gentrification of the Inner Harbor spread to
Neighborhoods like Butcher's Hill, Canton, Greektown, and Brewers Hill,
so too did the redevelopment of the waterfront. Mixed Use began moving
further and further southeast along Boston St. where unlike Inner Harbor
East, Canton's and Brewers Hills's Industrial Past was salvaged and
reused as loft Apartments, as well as Retail. There was also plenty of
new construction in Canton as well. Canton had its own version of
stalled mixed use development like Inner Harbor East; Canton Crossing.
At first Canton Crossing was little more than a lone
Office Building that housed the headquarters of First Mariner Bank and a
large penthouse Apartment owned by First Mariner Bank President and
Canton Crossing Developer Ed Hale. Due to the collapse of the economy in
2008, the Retail component of Canton Crossing had stalled and Ed Hale
had to sell off the land that was banked for Canton Crossing so he could
save the Bank from going under. After years of waiting the Shops at
Canton Crossing was completed and lots of chain stores that were only
available in the suburbs had arrived in the City.
Meanwhile, across from Canton Crossing where Canton
meets Brewers Hill meets Greektown, Apartment construction has been
continuing at a break neck pace. I also read in an article that there is
a high demand for Office Space in Canton in addition to the demand for
Office Space in Harbor Point and what has yet to be built in Inner
Harbor East. This southeasterly shift of Office Space from the Central
Business District has been remarkable, but how has the Central Business
District fared?
Given that this post is about how Mixed Use
Development in Baltimore has become the current development trend I'm
sure you know where this is going. As much as the there's now demand for
Office Space in Harbor Point, Harbor East, and Canton, there's as much
if not more demand for Residential development Downtown. The Central
Business District is now playing host to mixed use as well, 10 Light St.
is being converted into 445 luxury Apartments, as well as 301 N.
Charles St., and 114 E. Lexington St. are slated to do so as well. Also
in the Central Business District is 414 Water St. which is new
construction which are Condos not Apartments (pictured above). There have also been numerous Hotel recently built in the
Central Business District.
The future of the Central Business District and
areas directly surrounding will only add to the new Mixed Use feel of
Downtown. Vacant parcels such as 300 E. Pratt St.,(pictured above) the Conway St.
parking lot, and the Mechanic Opera House all have mixed use development
and redevelopment plans on the books. There were also plans to
redevelop 1st Mariner Arena by adding additional floors by Ed Hale's
financial problems put that on the back burner.
There has also been a demand for Residences in
Downtown's Westside. Residential towers both new and re-purposed have
been completed. The idea of re-converting the Westside back into
Baltimore's Retail destination have fallen flat however. It is unknown
if and when Retail will return to the Westside but it's comforting to
know that there's at least a small Residential renaissance.
Although the demand for Office Space in the
traditional Downtown area has gone down, the need for Residential space
in that same area has gone up. Also the demand for Office Space Citywide
has gone up it's just that the demand is in places that aren't the
traditional Central Business District. The end result is a plethora of
mixed use development throughout the City's gentrified areas that will
surely expand Baltimore's showcase.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)